TCGuardian vs Shipping Shield
Share
TCGuardian vs. Shipping Shield: Which Card Protector is Right for You?
If you’re serious about protecting your trading cards during delivery, a reliable shipping protector is crucial. Whether shipping across the country or storing at home, you need the best protection. TCGuardian and Shipping Shield—both are eco-friendly options, but how do they compare? Let’s break it down.
Price
Toploader Protector Price $.3 to $.115
Shipping Shield's paper costs less, but they charge you more... Moreover, given the potential drawbacks in terms of capacity and risk during shipping, the higher cost might not offer the best value for everyone.
Capacity
When it comes to capacity, TCGuardian outshines Shipping Shield. It’s designed to hold more cards, making it ideal for those who need to ship 11 mtg cards at once. This added space doesn’t compromise its protective qualities, ensuring your cards stay safe, whether you’re sending one or several.
Shipping Shield tends to be more restrictive in terms of capacity. Its rigid design limits how many cards you can comfortably fit inside, which might be fine for single cards but becomes problematic if you’re shipping multiples.
Why Thickness Alone Isn’t Enough
True quality comes from a well-balanced approach that ensures functionality, durability, and reliability, not just the thickness of the material. Our protectors excel in keeping your cards safe from bending, scratching, and other potential damage, while maximizing card capacity to support your trading card business profitability, not just the thickness of the material.. That’s the standard we’ve set for every product we offer.
Weight Matters: Save on Stamps and Avoid Returned Mail
One of the standout features of TCGuardian is its incredibly lightweight design. Each protector weighs just 0.17 oz, making it a fraction of the weight of a Shipping Shield, which tips the scales at 2 oz per protector. This difference might seem small, but it has a big impact when you’re shipping cards.
The lighter weight of TCGuardian not only makes it easier to handle and package but also significantly reduces your shipping costs. With lower postage requirements, you’ll save money on stamps—especially important if you’re regularly mailing cards. Plus, lighter packages are less likely to exceed weight limits, which means a lower risk of your mail being returned due to insufficient postage.
Shipping Shield, while offering robust protection, adds considerable weight to your package. At 2 oz per protector, you might find yourself paying more in postage, especially when shipping multiple cards. This additional weight can also increase the likelihood of your package being returned if you underestimate the postage needed.
Durability and Protection
TCGuardian is designed with durability in mind. Made from a flexible, yet sturdy material, it offers exceptional protection against bending and impacts. It’s thick enough to safeguard your cards, but not so rigid that it risks damaging them during shipping. The flexibility also means it won’t get caught in sorting machines, a common issue with stiffer protectors.
Shipping Shield, on the other hand, using lower quality waste paper. While this is cheaper to produce, the material is not durable and doesn't last long if you tape it too many times. If you want to reuse it and ship high valued cards, this is a factor worth considering.
For a card protector that balances protection, cost, and convenience, TCGuardian is the clear winner. Keep your cards safe without breaking the bank on postage—choose TCGuardian and enjoy peace of mind every time you ship.